Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Human Development and the US-Mexico Border

Andrew Sullivan links to a map from the 2009 Human Development Report, which uses HDI, the Human Development Index, as a measure of the general level of development for jurisdictions on both sides of the US-Mexico border:

us mexico border hdi map

As Steven Taylor notes:
What is interesting is that the lowest HDI county on the US side (Starr County Texas) is higher than the highest HDI municipality in Mexico (i.e., Mexicali).

This is, of course, likely not a shock to anyone paying even a modicum of attention to the situation. Still, it continues to underscore that fundamental aspect of this situation: it is the disparity of wealth between the two countries that continues to create the synergy of migration over the border. As I keep saying: any policy that ignores this fact will fail. As such, calls for massive deportations or that assumes it is possible to stop migration over the border is naught more than fantasy. “Seal the border!” is a slogan, not a viable policy.
That's true. It also points up what ought to be an obvious truth about immigration from Mexico and other relatively poor countries to the United States: it is comprised mostly of individuals who are driven by lack of economic opportunity to leave their homeland in order to exchange their labor for money. That many people feel so threatened by this class of people, which is already among the most powerless in society, has always baffled me.

Also: as long-time readers of this blog know, I like nothing better than using HDI for various countries as a frame of reference for apprehending the significance of HDI ratings for various sub-national jurisdictions! And so, here are selected HDI-comparable nations (based on this table (pdf) from the same organization) for each of the five HDI ranges indicated on the map (with countries listed in ascending order of HDI):

.636-.700 - Morocco, Botswana, South Africa, Tajikistan, Vanuatu, Kyrgyzstan, Guatemala, Nicaragua

.701-.765 - Uzbekistan, Honduras, Egypt, Vietnam, Mongolia, Bolivia, Indonesia, Philippines, El Salvador, Algeria, China, Georgia

.766-.830
- Dominican Republic, Jordan, Belize, Tonga, Ukraine, Thailand, Peru, Turkey, Kazakhstan, Brazil, Serbia, Malaysia, Venezuela

.831-.895
- Panama, Bulgaria, Oman, Mexico, Costa Rica, Cuba, Argentina, Lithuania, Chile, Hungary, Malta

.896-.950 - Czech Republic, Portugal, UAE, Singapore, Slovenia, South Korea, Israel, Germany, UK, Italy, Belgium, United States

50 comments:

La Migra said...

Why are people threatened by this class of people? So you are proposing the US just open the gate to all?

Anonymous said...

Why does it baffle you that SOME people would feel threatened? A very ignorant and divisive statement at best. What would be your solution to a real issue facing America and ALL of that dying geographical collective known as Western Europe? Or is it just easier for you to throw your hands in the air and say, "oh golly me. People are mean".

spread eagle beagle said...

I'm thinking Chachy's solution would have something to do with the redistibution of wealth... someone else's wealth that is. And that does not make me a racist.

Anonymous said...

"That many people feel so threatened by this class of people, which is already among the most powerless in society, has always baffled me."

Then maybe you should do some research, so you cam stop being baffled.

Anonymous said...

I'd hardly say they were powerless. The have the ACLU, the Democrats(albiet, only for votes), the, as Chomsky would say 'leftist elites', MALDEF, the media, and a host of others looking after them. The issue is about enforcing federal laws already on the books. If you want open borders, get rid of those laws. As a Republic, states have a right to enforce federal laws that the federal government won't. Am I getting off topic? BTW, open, honest disscusions on issues like this is extremely healthy.

Totally and Completely Resigned said...

Does this map tell us anything we don't already know? Sure, it's a sad plight (and an awesome one at that) but thus is the history of man. Some fresh solutions would be a little bit more uplifting than this regurgitated Christian-like armageddon bullshit I see peppering your blog. Chachy, what do your wrists look like? Fuck, man.

Chachy said...

What, no one wants to talk HDI comps?

Look, when I say I'm "baffled," I'm not saying I'm baffled by any particular policy prescription. Personally, I would favor loosening restrictions on legal immigration while tightening enforcement on employer hiring of illegal immigrants; but whatever. I'm not talking about policy, and I'm not baffled simply by the view that immigration ought to be restricted.

What baffles me is a certain nativist/xenophobic hostility towards (illegal, but sometimes all) immigrants that seems prominent, though surely not universal, in anti-immigrant activism. Arizona's SB 1070 was a case in point - it was pretty much designed to make life hard for immigrants, including legal ones. A more general case in point would be those ubiquitous signs you see at anti-illegal immigrant rallies: "What part of 'illegal' don't you understand?" and variations on that theme. To characterize people who, again, are driven by lack of economic opportunity to leave their homeland in order to exchange their labor for money as simply 'illegal,' full stop, end of discussion, is to reduce those people to mere excluded objects. It is dehumanizing, and bespeaks an inability to appreciate their experience from their point of view. But once you do make that fairly minimal empathic leap of imagining what life is like for someone in that condition, then I don't see how you can think of such people as inherently dangerous or criminal or a threat to the fabric of the nation or anything like that.

La Migra said...

The idea of one illegal immigrant is not intimidating. However, there are several inherent dangers to this "class" of people. You are obviously from the north.

1) They are a huge burden on the health care system. Everyone else pays more because they don't. And they end up in hospitals a plenty.

2)While they are not all criminals, they are breaking the law by coming here illegally.

And even more unfortunately, their former country is a huge stinking pile ridden with Cartels and a corrupt Gov.

While Jose may just want to cut your grass, Pablo just murdered a sheriff to sell his. In TX border towns sheriffs have been killed and their replacements killed a few days later. 1000s of people have been killed on our side of the border. While this might be conflating a couple of different issues ...how can you be non-discriminatory (good illegal vs. bad illegal)in ILLEGAl immigration or general border protection?

Noone is that worried about Jose cutting the grass...it's how he got here that worries everyone.

3)The "they do jobs Americans won't" arguement is ridiculous. They are being exploited for slave labor in our country. Our employers don't want to pay fair wages, payroll taxes and break the law. This has somehow been rationalized that this is just their first step toward the American dream and it's better than where they came from.

But in reality, they can get gunned down and have too many kids in our bad neighborhoods now.

I have one living in my condo assoc with this much older more wealthy chickenhawk. I'm not sure if he is really gay or he just needed a place to live that bad. He knocked on my door to report someone had hit my car and drove off. And I thought to myself, this poor illegal who gets old wrinkly balls slapping up against his ass isn't such a bad guy.

And indvidually not all of them are. However, this "class" of people is something people can be rightfully threatend by.

Richard said...

Threatened only because of ignorance and fear of difference. The hard facts are that illegal immigrants contribute more to the economy than they take (for one, they pay FICA while not taking SS).

Keeping out illegals also won't help you nativists keep/find jobs, so long as there is free flow of trade & capital and we don't invest in education. You'll just make more of the US look like (very white, very poor) Appalachia instead.

Gus Snarp said...

Wow, and I thought the global warming posts brought them out.

I say: Mr. Obama, tear down this wall!

And Legalize pot while you're at it, it's the cartels' most profitable product, without it they will dry up.

Chris said...

La Migra, can you provide a link for the multiple Texas sheriff murders? I couldn't find anything using Google.

It's really not surprising that the HDI is so different from the other side of an international border. I bet there are other examples out there. Might be interesting to see them on the Map Scroll. :)

Anonymous said...

It should be noted that immigrants, and illegal immigrants in particular, fill jobs which Americans, especially Americans who are legally entitled to various welfare benefits (housing, medical, income, food stamps, unemployment, etc.) would never deign to fill. For the most part, illegal immigrants fill jobs and perform services that Americans would not let their teenage child consider filling. Furthermore, these are services that the American population demands in order to maintain the level of wealth and ease that is available to most Americans. This includes cheaper food prices, services, labor, etc.
These immigrants, illegal or no, cannot be said to threaten American jobs, and there has yet to be any significant research that quantifies the general cost benefit of immigration, in terms of increasing Americans' wealth, versus whatever drain on welfare services such immigrants pose.
If anyone wants to persuasively argue against the benefits of immigrant labor, at all levels of the economy, including illegal immigrant labor, that argument cannot be considered credible unless such an opponent to immigration is willing to truly boycott all of the benefits of immigrant labor they currently enjoy.

Eye-catching Herve Leger dress said...

Moncler
moncler jacket
moncler jackets
moncler jacken
moncler branson
moncler online shop

herve leger dress
bandage dress
herve leger

Dsquared2 clothing
Dsquared sneakers for women
Dsquared2

Moncler Zapatos
Moncler Botas
moncler

lw said...

thanks for posting this

C said...

This seems to work!

led said...

Christian Louboutin Tall Boots
Christian Louboutin Wedges
Christian Louboutin Pumps
Christian Louboutin Sandals
Jimmy Choo Shoes
Moncler Kid's Jackets
Moncler clothing wholesale
Wholesale Moncler Jackets
discount Moncler Jackets
http://www.shopmoncler.hk/moncler-jackets
http://www.utsource.net/BUK444-500B.html
http://www.utsource.net/MG50Q6ES41.html
http://www.utsource.net/UM150CDY-10.html
http://www.utsource.net/MP7002.html
http://www.utsource.net/TMS320F2812PGFA.html
http://www.utsource.net/CEM3374.html
http://www.utsource.net/2sj74.html

dfadf said...

Microsoft Office
Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Office 2010 key
Office 2010 download
Office 2010 Professional
Microsoft outlook
Outlook 2010
Windows 7
Microsoft outlook 2010

weddingdresses said...

Are you preparing Christmas gifts for your loves ,family and friends now ?
Maybe you can choose us , we always provide the excellent quality products and best after-sale service ,

And recently we have a active promotions :Happy Shopping at Dec,
the content of preference:
10%~15% discount
a Christmas gift
Free shipping!

we are accept paypal ,credit card and western union for payment .
New arrival :Power Balance
winter boots
power balance bracelet
Silly Bands
Reebok Easytone
reebok zigtech
efx bracelet
Moncler Jackets

JUN said...

In this distress he was received into the house of Mr. Waldron, where he lay concealed for some time. When the place of his retreat was at length discovered, he took refuge in Flanders, whore he died after a mbt trainers few months' residence, in the summer of 1791.Under the hospitable roof of this worthy and amiable man, Whalley resumed the care of Jonson ; but want of books, and, perhaps, of sufficient composure of mind, rendered his attcmpte ineffectual, and the manuscript was finally abandoned to his friend, who, in the year 1792, coach outlet store online commenced the publication of it in numbers. The success apparently fell short of the expectations of the editor, as the work was not continued beyond the second number.Mr. Waldron neither possessed, nor pretended to be possessed of, scholastic learning; but he was laborious, accurate, conversant with the stage, and imbued with a rational love of the ancient drama, which he had studied coach bags outlet with success. He appears to have collated Whalley's copy with the early editions ; and, on attentively retracing his steps, previously to the arrangement of the text for the present publication, I found much to approve in the caution andI Whalley'« text was that of the booksellers' edition, five finger shoes in Svo. This had been in Theobald's band«, and an incidental remark by him, of no moment whatever, here and there appeared in Ule margin.judgment with which he had uniformly proceeded. His friendship for Whalley, however, has led him to form far too high an estimate of that gentleman's qualifications ; and beyond the revision which I have just mentioned, he seems to have contemplated no alteration of the papers left in his hands.Many years had elapsed since the failure, last mentioned, when the republication coach outlet coupon of Joneon w»s proposed to me by Mr. George Nicol, to whom Whalley'e corrected copy had been consigned by Mr. Waldron. I was well aware of the labor and difficulty of the task ; but my objections were overcome by the encouragement of my friend, and I undertook the edition, confident that I was not about to coach purses outlet encumber the public with a superfluous work, for Jonson had now been long out of the bookseller's hands. One motive there yet was, which had some influence on my determination — a desire, though late, to render justice to the moral character of the author, and rescue him from the calumnies of his inveterate persecutors. My mind had been prejudiced at an early period by the commentators on our old dramas, and I verily believed, as they repeatedly assured me, that " tho great mbt shoes clearance object of Jonson's life was the persecution of Shakspeare ; " nor was it until I became acquainted with the dates of his respective performances that I ventured to question the accuracy of the critics, or to entertain a suspicion that they were actuated by unworthy motives, and could only be relieved 5 finger shoes from the charge of wanton malevolence by the plea of incorrigible folly.Previously to the arrangement of the text, it became necessary to collate the old editions. In the execution of this part of the work, the mode adopted in the revision of Maesinger was carefully followed.

Luxury ZONE said...

top sites to buy from
Movado Watch
Baby Carriers
power balance
winter boots
ecco shoes
Bakugan Toys

glenda regan said...

Juicy Couture Clothes
juicy couture Tracksuit
Juicy Couture Sandals
Juicy Couture Earrings
Juicy Couture Flip Flops
Juicy Couture Bracelets
Juicy Couture Purse
Juicy Couture Swimwear
Juicy Couture T-Shirt
Juicy Couture Sunglass
Dsquared Clothes
Dsquared Shoes
Dsquared Belt
Dsquared Cap
Dsquared Hoodies
Dsquared Jeans
Dsquared Suit
Dsquared Sport Pants
Dsquared Shirt
Dsquared Polo
Dsquared T-shirt
Dsquared Swimwear
Tommy Hilfiger Clothes
Tommy Hilfiger T-Shirt
Tommy Hilfiger Polo
Tommy Hilfiger Jeans
Tommy Hilfiger Sweater
Tommy Hilfiger Flip Flops

Sinus headache said...

Your post is really good providing good information Baby ear infection Prevent prostate cancer Prevent prostate cancer Lemon tea healh benefits Lemon tea healh benefits Prevent candida yeast infection Prevent candida yeast infection Health benefits of papaya Health benefits of papaya Benefits of peppermint oil Benefits of peppermint oil Stop hiccups Stop hiccups Water and weight loss Water and weight loss Wart Removal Wart Removal Health benefits of oatmeal
Benefits of tea tree oil Common digestive system diseases and disorders Health benefits of saltHealth benefits of salt Prevent wrinkles naturally

oakley radar said...

Oakley sunglasses outlet is of the worldwide popularity.Here you can find out great wholesale discount of oakley radar sunglasses and oakley frogskins with all the latest styles.
Oakley sunglasses outlet is of the worldwide popularity.Here you can find out great wholesale discount of oakley radar sunglasses and oakley frogskins with all the latest styles.

acekard 2i 3ds said...

r4 card
nds card
r4idsn
r4i ds
r4 cards
r4i sdhc
r4itt

r4 firmware
m3 ds real firmware
dstt firmware
r4i gold kernel
wood r4

рестораны в барселоне said...

Quite helpful data, lots of thanks for your article.

better ck said...

Thank you for posting insightful articles.
stop pre ejaculation
home treatments for hemorrhoids
easy online business
No.1 Natural Cure From Japan
Proven Natural Cure For Eyes

Yani Maryatul Ulpah said...

Berita Terbaru
Jadwal MotoGP 2012 Terbaru
Gemscool
kata kata bijak
Kata Kata Mutiara Cinta
Trik Internet Gratis Indosat
Klasemen Liga Europa
Kata Mutiara Terbaik
Indosiar TV Online Streaming Indonesia
Kata Kata Bijak Mario Teguh
Prediksi Togel Hari Ini
Cara Download Video Youtube
Smadav Pro 9
Cheat Lost Saga Indonesia
USPS Insurance Rates
4shared
Trik Internet Gratis HP XL

album foto said...

I think people fear idea management and innovation because there's a significant number of ideas that simply won't plan out.......Nice statement.....keep posting

asuransi pendidikan said...

this day I've been searching for information on various issues, this I found very good and I would like to congratulate you for your work.

design interior jakarta said...

I think that this post is one of the best that i have read in my life, congrats you did a great job,.

perusahaan security said...

the difference between the content spammers and most corporate innovators is that the smaller

jual wine said...

I'm writing to you because I just came across a business that I think has great potential. It lets you save money on almost everything. Make money from almost everything,

coklat valentine said...

If growth is important to a firm, and if growth is dependent on offering existing products and services to new customers

belajar internet marketing said...

innovation is very natural and happens in the "real world" as new plants and animals colonize new ecological niches.

konsultan perusahaan said...

I wonder how you got so good. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect

kuliner bandung said...

We generally think most specifically about the risk associated with a new product introduction

how to stay erect said...

I would be aware that as somebody who really doesn’t comment to blogs a lot (in actual fact, this may be my first put up), I don’t think the time period “lurker” is very flattering to a non-posting reader.

Kamagra said...

This is really fantastic work friend..The Way in which You represent this blog is awesome.I really appreciate your work. Keep it up in future.

puisi romantis said...

Berita Terbaru | Youtube | kata bijak | kata mutiara | gemscool | 4shared | cerita lucu | contoh surat lamaran kerja | mivo tv | zodiak | Indowebster | kata mutiara cinta | tv online | puisi cinta | Software Akuntansi Laporan Keuangan Terbaik | Smadav | Pantun Jenaka | Lagu Terbaru | Harga Blackberry | Harga Hp | Edit Foto | kata kata gombal | kata kata cinta | kata kata motivasi

4shared said...

Video Lucu
Hidup Sehat
Install Windows 7
Windows XP
Install Windows XP
Cara Belajar Bahasa Inggris
Makanan Berbahaya
Cara Mendidik Anak
MyTrans

Cinema3satu Megaupload

Toyota Avanza Terbaru

Harga Mobil Suzuki Video Aneh Point Blank Kanker Payudara Komik Naruto Bahasa Indonesia Kata Cinta Daftar Mobil Smadav IDM Cinema XII

Hello

Google Chrom said...

Like this same with 4shared | Gemscool | Point Blank | Point Blank | Cara Mendidik Anak | Video Bayi Lucu | Video Gunung Meletus | Video Aneh





conclution nice information for me :)

Promo Member Alfamart Minimarket Lokal Terbaik Indonesia - Promo - 4shared - Download Counter Strike - Google Chrom

Warcraft | Cinema xxi | Kata Cinta | Komik Naruto Bahasa Indonesia | Cara Bersalin Normal


Google Chrom
Gemscool

Video Lucu said...

nice information for me :)

Promo Member Alfamart Minimarket Lokal Terbaik Indonesia - Promo - 4shared - Download Counter Strike - Google Chrom

Warcraft | Cinema xxi | Kata Cinta | Komik Naruto Bahasa Indonesia | Cara Bersalin Normal


Google Chrom
Gemscool
Video Youtube
TV ONline
tv streaming
tv internet
IEEE
Artis Terseksi
Video Hantu
Point Blank Indonesia
waptrick
Game Perang
Promo Member Alfamart Minimarket Lokal Terbaik Indonesia
Promo

Promo Member Alfamart Minimarket Lokal Terbaik Indonesia
Promo
Server Dota

nice car said...

car review
Fashion Mode

Zodiak said...

Kata-Kata Mutiara
Kata Mutiara
Kata Mutiara Bijak
Kata Mutiara CInta
Kata Bijak
Kata-Kata bijak
Kata-Kata Mutiara bijak
Harga Notebook
Ultrabook Notebook Tipis
Ramalan Zodiak
Zodiak hari ini
Zodiak
Cara Membuat Surat Lamaran
Contoh Surat Lamaran
Contoh Surat Lamaran Kerja

qinbincai123 said...

Your forever friend gets you through the jnjjnd81 hard times,the sad times,and the confused times.
Cheap Snapback Hats
Cheap New Era Hats
Wholesale New Era Hats
Wholesale 59fifty Hats
Monster Energy Hats

Anonymous said...

Great job! if you are free, take a look at http://www.nflhatsales.com/

Azis Sofyan said...

InfoNewbi
ZayCoel
Memperbaiki power supply
Membuat Jaringan
memperbaiki hardisk
cara merawat laptop
Download Ebook Komputer
Cara Memperbaiki Laptop
Cara Membersihkan Monitor
Toko Online Ebook Komputer
Cara Memperbaiki Komputer
Cara Mahir Memperbaiki Komputer dan Laptop

Download smadav terbaru Revisi
Download corel draw x5 gratis
Download corel draw x6 terbaru Full Gratis
Download Avast Terbaru
Download Kaspersky Terbaru Gratis
Download Aplikasi Android Terbaru
Download Mozilla FireFox Terbaru
Download Kakao Talk Android

Tips Agar Cepat Hamil
Cara Root Android
kata indah
Harga Smartfren andromax i

ebook komputer said...

Baca Komik Manga Online Terbaru
Cara Mudah Memperbaiki Motherboard
Cara Edit Foto Menjadi Gambar Kartun
Memperbaiki Monitor LCD
Cara Memperbaiki Printer
Cara Belajar Komputer Dengan Benar
Cara Merakit Komputer
Download Photoshop cs 6 terbaru
Edit Foto dengan Photoshop
Download FIlm 5 Cm
Cara Download Video Youtube
Cara Memperbaiki Hardisk
Memperbaiki BIOS
Flashdisk Tidak Bisa Di Format
Download Film Resident Evil 5 Gratis
Harga bb Terbaru

sohbet said...

very blog
sohbet & sohbet siteleri
chat sohbet & kelebek sohbet & kelebek chat
kelebek indir & mirc indir &kelebek sohbet
kelebek chat & sohbet odalari & sohbet
cinsel sohbet & cinsel chat &
urfa & urfa haber
sohbet & chat
kelebek sohbet & kelebek chat
chat yap & sohbet kanalları
sohbet kanalı & chat kanalı &
mynet sohbet & mynet & mirc indir
mirc & sohbet odaları
dul bayan & olgun bayan

mariya01 said...

This blog was... how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I have found something which helped me.
Appreciate it!
Tag Heuer Cell phones