Thursday, January 7, 2010

Urban Growth Regulation in the US

Paul Krugman points to another be-mapped Brookings report, this one on the growth typologies of the 50 largest US metro areas. Here's the map Krugman posts - it shows typology of land use regulation by metro area:

city growth regulation type map

They found that cities followed a few different patterns of growth regulation regimes, which they classify into four orders:

Traditional. This covers 34 metros and 75 million people. In these areas, "planning and zoning remains mostly voluntary, few local governments engage in innovative land-use regulation, and state review of local plans is mostly absent. These are also highly 'fragmented' metropolitan areas with large numbers of local governments, each of which regulates land use based mainly on its own calculus." Densities are falling faster in these areas than elsewhere, and they tend to offer fewer housing opportunities for low-income residents.

Exclusion. These areas regulate against the construction of low-density apartment complexes, and "share a comparatively low use of tools to require that development 'pay its own way'.” Housing prices tend to be relatively high in these areas.

Wild Wild Texas. The Lone Star State is sui generis, its cities less restricted than any others in the country, partly because zoning and comprehensive growth plans are both disallowed for Texas counties. These cities have some of the lowest housing prices, but note that this report was from 2006, the height of the housing bubble.

Reform. These metros use a broad range of tools to regulate and manage development. Central cities in these areas tend to be more prosperous, with more college graduates and homeowners, than in the Exclusion and Traditional areas. (This goes for Texas as well.) The growth control group within this family has thte highest housing prioes in the country.

One thing worth noting is that, though the essentially deregulated environment in Texas is characterized by affordable housing and (in 2010) one of the least bad state economies (not saying much), this is largely due to the existence of uncharacteristically progressive regulations in the mortgage market which kept the housing bubble at bay in Texas' biggest cities. And, of course, the affordability of these cities has lots of external costs in the form of environmental impacts, particularly the worsening of global warming engendered by all that new sprawl. Meanwhile, the report says that reform cities generally offer the best opportunities for minorities (again, ca. 2006; but these areas are generally getting hammered economically right now); and that they succeed when they are oriented towards growth management rather than growth control, the latter of which suppresses development in already built areas.

Krugman makes a further point:
Oh, and someone will surely raise the claim that this shows that you mustn’t have “smart growth” policies because they cause housing bubbles. Can I say that this is deeply stupid? On one side, we’re supposed to believe that markets are efficient and wonderful; on the other, we’re supposed to believe that anything which constrains buildable land — which, you know, sometimes happens for entirely natural reasons — will send markets into wild irrational swings. Those poor, fragile, omnipotent markets, able to handle anything except mild government intervention …
I more or less agree with this sentiment, though I wouldn't necessarily call the opposing view "deeply stupid." I think that on the one hand, a truly deregulated growth environment is sort of like what Ghandi said about Western democracy: it would be a nice idea and we whould try it some time. Even cities like Houston have lots of regulations about how cities can be built, for instance, employing minimum parking space requirements that exacerbate sprawl. (I actually don't know if a truly unregulated city growth pattern would be a 'nice idea,' but it would be interesting to have one such American city as a test case.) But on the other hand, I think what you get from a radically free market in urban development is what you usually get from radically free markets: a tremendous ability to satisfy consumer demand in the short-term, plus horrendous externalized costs (environmental degradation, including global warming, and so forth) and other terrible consequences that tend to mount over the long term, and which private individuals have little incentive to account for.

25 comments:

Andrew B said...

Almost all the cities marked as Traditional except High Density NYC are super cheap to live, have plenty of housing available in all ranges, and tons of low-income housing thanks to the existence of large inner cities. Those places plus Texas are affordable for everyone, from poor to rich. Everywhere else is ridiculously overpriced. I very much disagree with the idea that: "they tend to offer fewer housing opportunities for low-income residents". Inner city houses in many of these areas can be had for $50K or less.

Richard said...

You know, for a smart guy, Krugman isn't very able to see opposing views (though I enjoy his rants; mostly because he's an entertaining writer). In any case, you can take the view (as I do) that markets are not efficient all the time, thus more regulation can cause wilder gyrations in housing prices, but (just like democracy in politics), lightly-regulated markets (even though an inherently unstable system) are the best of all the imperfect economic systems out there.

You don't have to believe in market efficiency to be an economic libertarian. Krugman makes the basic mistake of conflating 2 different types of economic conservatives yet has the chutzpah to call other people stupid....

daftar oriflame online said...

I like to see your maps, thanks

healthy sharing said...

Considerably, this post is really the sweetest on this notable topic. I harmonise with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your incoming updates. Saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the phenomenal clarity in your writing. I will directly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates. Admirable work and much success in your business dealings!.Please excuse my poor English as it is not my first tongue. free download music

longge said...

Remember that a stylish Coach Purses needs only to be able to carry your cell phone, money and perhaps a lipstick; the rest is all about how it looks while you carry it. To be able to buy a Coach Legacy from a quality boutique is not an easy job, go only if you are affluent enough as some Coach Luggage in a quality boutique, will cost more than $ 10000 or even more. Certain degrees of knowledge is quite necessary if you plan to buy a costly Coach Madison , regarding the latest trends, colors and styles that are in at that time.

Breitling Watch crafted the Breitling Avenger to be able of advertence 24 hours in one individual ambit of the dial, because in amplitude there is no acumen amid day and night. The new adaptation of the Navitimer World will absorb this affection as able-bodied as the iconic 60’s design. 1,000 of these new Montbrillant Datora watches will be produced.


The best source of getting Christian Louboutin shoes with spending just a few bucks is to purchase Christian Louboutin Sandals from our online store. This store makes it possible for every woman to make these stylish Christian Louboutin Pumps a part of her wardrobe. This amazing online store that my friend told me about, manufacture high class replicas of classic designer shoes that are economical as well as stylish. Their Christian Louboutin Boots are the exact replicas of the original ones, as they deeply scan the design, anatomy and composition of the shoe.

tn requin said...

sleeping bag
tablecloth
travel luggage
car gps
car parts
GPS navigation
portable GPS
lcd tv
flat tv
digital picture frames
unlocked cell phones
wedding dresses
wedding jewelry
chaussures mode
chaussures Femmes
women's shoes
round tablecloth
discount handbags
chaussures sport
chaussures pas cher
fashion bedding
id lanyard
lanyard
creative gadgets
gift ideas
kids wall stickers
wall stickers
bath curtains
kitchen faucet
bathroom faucet

Sildenafil Citrate said...

interesting date you have posted here, I was doing a research on this particular subject actually and I wish I could have found your good blog before, thank you anyway!

dfadf said...

Microsoft Office
Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Office 2010 key
Office 2010 download
Office 2010 Professional
Microsoft outlook
Outlook 2010
Windows 7
Microsoft outlook 2010

justin bieber said...

You know, for a smart guy, Krugman isn't very able to see opposing views (though I enjoy his rants; Inner city houses in many of these areas can be had for $50K or less.

Sinus headache said...

Your post is really good providing good information Baby ear infection Prevent prostate cancer Prevent prostate cancer Lemon tea healh benefits Lemon tea healh benefits Prevent candida yeast infection Prevent candida yeast infection Health benefits of papaya Health benefits of papaya Benefits of peppermint oil Benefits of peppermint oil Stop hiccups Stop hiccups Water and weight loss Water and weight loss Wart Removal Wart Removal Health benefits of oatmeal
Benefits of tea tree oil Common digestive system diseases and disorders Health benefits of saltHealth benefits of salt Prevent wrinkles naturally Tighten sagging skin Dry skin patches treatmentDry skin patches Get rid of acneGet rid of acne Driving tips Migraine headache remedies Migraine headache

roger vivier said...

We are offering you a chance to form long-term business partnerships with Oakley sunglasses outlet on sale 60% off,free shipping, an opportunity that you.The subversion of concept that cheap oakley radar glasses on glasses products is that it integrate the comfortable vzkjvnzk , practical, artistic of a sunglass in one.By having a tent such as this oakley frogskins Sunglasses Outlet Store, you might be wholly in the shade and guarded from your sun and wind in.

Cerita Seks said...

Inner city houses in many of these areas can be had for $50K or less Cerita Seks, Cerita Dewasa

Panas
, Cewek Bugil, Cewek Indo Bugil,

Foto Cewek Bugil, Foto Gadis SMA, Memek Cewek, Cerita Dewasa, Cerita Dewasa Terbaru

Permainan Online Memasak said...

You know, for a smart guy, Krugman isn't very able to see opposing views (though I enjoy his rants
Dating Tips . Fist Dating . First Dating Tips . Get Rid Of Hickey Tips . Rid of Blackheads Naturally

www.josemoretsa.es said...

Well, I do not really imagine it is likely to have effect.

felicity said...

Fascinating article- I must say. I'm glad to have found this blog because I recently entertained the idea that hardly anything is original anymore. thanks very much for the share...
stop pre ejaculation
home treatments for hemorrhoids
easy online business
No.1 Natural Cure From Japan
Proven Natural Cure For Eyes

albumfoto said...

I think people fear idea management and innovation because there's a significant number of ideas that simply won't plan out.......Nice statement.....keep posting

belajar internet marketing said...

this day I've been searching for information on various issues, this I found very good and I would like to congratulate you for your work.

asuransi pendidikan said...

I think that this post is one of the best that i have read in my life, congrats you did a great job,.

perusahan security said...

the difference between the content spammers and most corporate innovators is that the smaller

jual wine said...

I'm writing to you because I just came across a business that I think has great potential. It lets you save money on almost everything. Make money from almost everything,

coklat valentine said...

If growth is important to a firm, and if growth is dependent on offering existing products and services to new customers

belajar internet marketing said...

innovation is very natural and happens in the "real world" as new plants and animals colonize new ecological niches.

kuliner bandung said...

I wonder how you got so good. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect

konsultan perusahaan said...

We generally think most specifically about the risk associated with a new product introduction

how to stay erect said...

I would be aware that as somebody who really doesn’t comment to blogs a lot (in actual fact, this may be my first put up), I don’t think the time period “lurker” is very flattering to a non-posting reader.