Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Is the US Becoming a Third World Country?

The simplest way to say whether a country is rich or poor is to add up its cumulative wealth, which is usually stated in terms of GDP. Sometimes this number is divided by the number of people in a country to say what the average wealth is: GDP per capita. And for a lot of purposes, including the overall economic strength of a country in an international context, that's a useful definition of wealth. But it's not a sufficient criterion for determining whether a society is wealthy. For instance, it's theoretically possible that a country could have a larger per capita GDP than any other country on the planet, but also for all that wealth to be controlled by a single autocratic leader to whom everyone else is enslaved. In the crudest economic terms, that society could be considered wealthy, even though all but one person would be utterly impoverished. So to determine whether a society is truly wealthy, some account needs to be taken of the distribution of wealth.

Here's a map I made of income inequality in the US.



This map is based on numbers from the US census (pdf). It uses the Gini index to measure income inequality. Gini
indicates how much the income distribution differs from a proportionate distribution (one where everyone would have the same income; for example, 20 percent of the population would hold 20 percent of the income, 40 percent of the population would hold 40 percent of the income, etc.). The Gini index varies from 0 to 1, where 0 indicates perfect equality (a proportional distribution of income), and 1 indicates perfect inequality (where one person has all the income and no one else has any).
So the higher the number, the more wealth inequality there is. For most advanced industrial economies, the Gini number is pretty low. According the the CIA World Factbook (table compiled here), the lowest Gini score in the world is Sweden's, at .23, followed by Denmark and Slovenia at .24. The next 20 countries are all in either Western Europe or the former Communist bloc of Eastern Europe. The EU as a whole is at .307. Russia has the highest number in Europe (.41); Portugal is the highest in Western Europe (.38). Japan is at .381; Australia is .352; Canada is .321.

And then there is the United States, sandwiched between Cote d'Ivoire and Uruguay at .450. Not counting Hong Kong (.523), the US is a complete loner among developed countries. In fact, as you can see from the map above, there is no overlap between any single US state and any other developed country; no state is within the normal range of income distribution in the rest of the developed world. Here's a list of the states with their Gini index numbers, and the country where income distribution is most comparable in parentheses:

Alabama - .472 (Nepal)
Alaska - .417 (Cambodia)
Arizona - .454 (Jamaica)
Arkansas - .460 (Ecuador)
California - .466 (Rwanda)
Colorado - .450 (Uruguay)
Connecticut - .480 (Venezuela)
Delaware - .434 (Guyana)
District of Columbia - .537 (Honduras)
Florida - .467 (Rwanda)
Georgia - .461 (Mexico)
Hawaii - .438 (Nigeria)
Idaho - .421 (Thailand)
Illinois - .462 (Malaysia)
Indiana - .432 (Guyana)
Iowa - .424 (Burundi)
Kansas - .441 (Kenya)
Kentucky - .460 (Ecuador)
Louisiana - .475 (Madagascar)
Maine - .428 (Singapore)
Maryland - .433 (Guyana)
Massachusetts - .461 (Mexico)
Michigan - .444 (Philippines)
Minnesota - .430 (Iran)
Mississippi - .471 (Nepal)
Missouri - .449 (Cote d'Ivoire)
Montana - .426 (Singapore)
Nebraska - .430 (Iran)
Nevada - .434 (Turkey)
New Hampshire - .417 (Cambodia)
New Jersey - .458 (Uganda)
New Mexico - .457 (Uganda)
New York - .495 (Costa Rica)
North Carolina - .458 (Uganda)
North Dakota - .434 (Guyana)
Ohio - .449 (Cote d'Ivoire)
Oklahoma - .460 (Ecuador)
Oregon - .444 (Kenya)
Pennsylvania - .455 (Jamaica)
Rhode Island - .442 (Philippines)
South Carolina - .462 (Mexico)
South Dakota - .439 (Nigeria)
Tennessee - .468 (Rwanda)
Texas - .474 (Mozambique)
Utah - .410 (Russia)
Vermont - .420 (Thailand)
Virginia - .456 (Uganda)
Washington - .443 (Kenya)
West Virginia - .447 (Cameroon)
Wisconsin - .424 (Burundi)
Wyoming - .413 (Senegal)

Obviously, the US is far wealthier than any of the countries to which states are being compared on this list; but it's striking to see the US fit a pattern which, outside of the US, is exclusively a phenomenon of the underdeveloped world.

But does that mean that the US is on the road to Third World-dom? Well, not necessarily - and not yet, at least. But it should give some context to comparisons of wealth between societies. For instance, the GDP per capita in the US is one of the highest in the world. But more of that wealth is concentrated in the hands of relatively few people, meaning fewer people (relative to that high per capita GDP) are well-off.

Matt Yglesias posted this chart the other day:

So even though a lot of wealth has been created since the 1970s, the typical family isn't much better off. And as Yglesias points out: "Another country with a lower GDP but less inequality could still be a country in which most people are richer than most Americans, and I believe there’s pretty compelling evidence that that’s now the case in a number of European countries."

I would add this: to the extent that wealth matters, it's because wealth increases the well-being of individuals. But there's undeniably a law of diminishing returns: a billionaire is not going to be a thousand times happier than a millionaire just because he has a thousand times as much money. In fact, I would argue that beyond some modest threshold - maybe below an income of $100,000/year - having more money simply doesn't affect one's well-being in any significant way. People certainly desire more wealth, mainly as a positional good - a billionaire has a higher status than a millionaire. But jockeying for positional goods is a zero-sum game; the billionaire's gain is the millionaire's loss, and so overall well-being is not increased by creating more wealth if that wealth just ends up getting shuttled up the income ladder into those stratospheric heights. In other words, if a country becomes wealthier because rich people are getting richer while everyone else treads water, that country is no better off than it was before. And if that's the case for a given country while more wealth is being created in other countries where it isn't being concentrated solely in the hands of the very rich, then that country's well-being, relative to other countries, decreases. That's what's been going on in the US for the last few decades. It's a sign of decline.

But not an irreversible one; the US doesn't have to become a third world country, where the majority of the population struggles to take care of basic needs while a minority controls a huge proportion of the nation's wealth. And an economic crisis, in large part brought about by wealthy elites mishandling their economic power, might be just the thing to start turning the trend around.

630 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   601 – 630 of 630
Super P Force said...

Yeah!
It can be happen and that is godd!

Unknown said...

Such an awesome content! Top 10 Health Benefits Of Mangoes

Unknown said...

Yes!!
The United States is the very powerful country as compare to other.
And I am proud to be US's citizen.
Follow -->>
Best Place to Buy Generic Viagra Online
Buy Lovegra Online
Buy Silagra Online at Epharmarx

Unknown said...

Thanks extremely valuable. Will certainly share website with my buddies
http://shlpharmacy.com/Viagra

Unknown said...

nice

Ektarao- Our Escorts at Chennai Escorts Agency with sexy and Beautiful Escorts girls.


busty Chennai escorts girls

escorts in Chennai

escorts service in Chennai

call girls in Chennai

Unknown said...

hello

Vchennaiescorts- Our Agency provide provide the Elite high class and Independent companion in Chennai to the customerwith geniune rates


collage girls in Chennai escorts

Chennai escorts models

Best Escort Service in Chennai

High Profile Escorts in Chennai

Anonymous said...

Bangalore escorts girls offers attractive, surprising and delightful Female escorts service in Bangalore..

Independent Escorts in Bangalore
Collage Girls in Bangalore escorts
Russian Escorts in Bangalore
Bangalore Female escorts

Unknown said...

vipchennaiescort-Hire our escorts for enjoying the pleasure of our latest escorts

Chennai escort
Chennai escorts service
Chennai escorts agency
independent Chennai escorts
escorts in Chennai

Unknown said...

chennaiescortsqueen-naughty chennai escorts ready for serve you
collage girls in Chennai escorts
Chennai escorts models
Best Escort Service in Chennai
Hot Escort Service in Chennai
VIP Escorts Service in Chennai

guaranteed cash loans said...

The truth is that some of the online same day loans lending websites out there are nothing more than traps for scammers. With the many cases of identity theft, you have every personal loans reason to be cautious.

guaranteed approval loan said...

Clearly, there are many distinct Guaranteed cash advance same day benefits of online personal loans, making them a viable option for many with damaged credit. But how do you choose the best lending payday loans partner from which to borrow your cash?

payday loans online same day said...

In a bid to cover the broad market, conventional payday loans lenders have cropped up and with options like Quicken; borrowers don’t have to be customers. This is opposite to what most banks and credit unions online payday loan practice and it has opened

Anonymous said...

تور تایلند
تور پاتایا
تور پوکت
تور سامویی
تور بانکوک
تور چیانگ مای

Anonymous said...

تور تایلند

Anonymous said...

تور
تور تایلند
تور پاتایا
تور پوکت
تور سامویی
تور بانکوک
تور چیانگ مای

Best Smartwatches 2019 said...

https://gaminglaptops11.blogspot.com

RAVI SING said...

Thanks for Sharing your valuable Information. I really like this post.

funker said...

Custom Design

Al-Habib Marketing said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Scott said...

my name is scott, I was heartbroken because i had very small penis, not nice to satisfy a woman, i had so many relationship cut off because of my situation, i have used so many product which i found online but none could offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments about this specialist called Dr OKISIN and decided to email him at dr.okisinsolutiontemple@gmail.com, so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal pills for Penis Enlargement, Within 14days of it, i began to feel the enlargement of my penis, " and now it just 2 weeks of using his products my penis is about 9 inches longer and i so happy contact DR OKISIN now via email dr.okisinsolutiontemple@gmail.com or his Whatsapp number +2348109374702. may God reward you for your good work.

Ari said...

Good Information

https://pemerintahan.uma.ac.id/
http://fisipol.uma.ac.id/
uma.ac.id

Callie Edorra said...

Hello,
This is a good blog post shared here.. Thanks for sharing such a unique post..
Women Leather Jumpsuit

Admin said...

At Infinix Logo, we believe in complete customer satisfaction according to their requirements and we provide complete custom logo designs with our professional designing skills.
Custom Logo Design Company

Jeff said...

Best Logo and web design in USA
Amazing use of comprehension and writing skills. 10/10 for the writers.

anna joy said...

The most effective and reliable solution to treat erectile dysfunction (ED) can be found in Vidalista 20 mg capsules. Sexual disorders include erectile dysfunction(ED), male impotence, etc. Vidalista 20mg as well as Cialis both contain the same active ingredient, generic Tadalafil and both medications are prescribed with the same reason, which seeks to relieve ED Vidalista 20 mg. If you consume any product that contains grapefruit, don't make use of the Vidalista 20 pills because grape juice can affect the effectiveness of the drugs. Aurogra 100, Vega 100

Pijari.com said...

Great post! Thanks for sharing

cara pakai tudung shawl bawal
petua hilangkan gatal kemaluan
cara ikat mata kail
cara bayar unifi jompay
ukur saiz cincin
cara hilangkan gam gajah pada tangan
pam susu elektrik terbaik
cara hilangkan dark circle
cara claim insurans kereta
password wifi mcd

John Buffet said...

Great post!! thanks for sharing!

James Gambil said...

"Logovent: Logo Design Agency USA  for Creating Your Brand Identity. At Logovent, we recognize the value of a visually arresting and enduring logo in showcasing your company's identity.

Gregory Homer said...

"WebsLeagues: Website Design company USA. Our specialty at WebsLeagues is offering creative, tailored website design solutions to companies all around the country.

Herbert Matson said...

App Leagues: Renowned for exceptional Web app development Service. Tailored, resilient applications. Expert team, cutting-edge technology. Outstanding outcomes.

«Oldest ‹Older   601 – 630 of 630   Newer› Newest»